Jump to content

Jenny Tonge, Baroness Tonge

Extended-protected article
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Jennifer Louise Tonge)

The Baroness Tonge
Member of the House of Lords
Lord Temporal
In office
27 June 2005 – 19 February 2021
Life Peerage
Member of Parliament
for Richmond Park
In office
2 May 1997 – 11 April 2005
Preceded byConstituency established
Succeeded bySusan Kramer
Personal details
Jennifer Louise Smith

(1941-02-19) 19 February 1941 (age 83)
Walsall, England, UK
Political partyIndependent (2016–present)
Other political
Liberal Party (1959[1]–88)
Liberal Democrats (1988–2012)
Independent Liberal Democrat (2012–2016)
SpouseKeith Tonge (m. 1964–2013, his death)
Alma materUniversity College, London

Jennifer Louise Tonge, Baroness Tonge (née Smith; born 19 February 1941) is a politician in the United Kingdom. She was Liberal Democrat Member of Parliament (MP) for Richmond Park in London from 1997 to 2005. In June 2005 she was made a life peer as Baroness Tonge, of Kew in the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames,[2] which entitled her to a seat in the House of Lords.

Critical of Israel and vocal in support of the Palestinian cause, controversial acts and comments led to accusations of anti-Semitism and to her eventual suspension from the Liberal Democrats group in the Lords in 2012, then her suspension and resignation from the party itself in October 2016. She sat as an independent in the Lords from 2012 until her retirement in 2021.[3][4]

Early life

Born in Walsall, Staffordshire, her parents were both schoolteachers.[5] She attended Dudley Girls High School from 1951 to 1959. She trained to be a doctor at University College Hospital, gaining an MB and BS in 1964.

She is also MFFP (Membership of the Faculty of Family Planning and Reproductive Health Care of the RCOG). She holds an honorary FFFP[clarification needed]. From 1968–78, she worked in General Practice and Family Planning. From 1980 to 1985, she worked as Senior Medical Officer in Women's Services in Ealing. She was a manager of Community Health Services in Ealing from 1992 to 1996.[citation needed]

Tonge was a councillor in the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames from 1981 to 1990, and served as chair of the Social Services Committee. She stood as the Liberal Democrat candidate for the Richmond and Barnes constituency at the 1992 general election. It was considered to be the party's most winnable seat, but Tonge was not elected.[6]

Parliamentary career

Member of Parliament

Election and PMQs

In 1997, Tonge was elected to Parliament, representing Richmond Park. While in the House of Commons, she was Liberal Democrat spokesperson on International Development from 1997 to 2003, and then the party spokesperson for children from 2003 to 2004.[7]

In 2002, during the Emmanuel College creationism controversy, she asked Prime Minister Tony Blair if he was "happy to allow the teaching of creationism alongside Darwin's theory of evolution in state schools". Blair replied that he supported a "diverse school system", and praised the teachers at Emmanuel College for their commitments to "deliver[ing] better results for our children".[8] Tonge was concerned about Blair's response, because it implied the government was "prepared to accept money from anybody, regardless of the doctrine or religious beliefs of the donor".[9]

Visit to Gaza Strip (2003)

In 2003, Tonge and Labour MP Oona King visited the Gaza Strip. At a subsequent press conference after their return, Tonge compared Gaza Strip living conditions for Palestinians to conditions Jews had suffered in the Warsaw Ghetto during World War II. Tonge said "You are almost getting a situation like the Warsaw ghetto. People can't get in or out. They can't work, they can't sell anything. There is this gradual squeeze", adding "It was an apartheid system." Tonge recommended economic sanctions be applied against Israel and for European Union or United Nations troops be sent to Gaza. Tonge and King claimed that an Israeli soldier wielding a grenade had confronted them when they tried to leave the Gaza Strip.[10]

Yad Vashem museum chair Avner Shalev criticized Tonge and King for making the comparison with conditions under Nazi rule.[11]

Palestinian suicide bombers (2004)

In January 2004, Tonge was sacked as the Liberal Democrat children's spokeswoman by the party leader, Charles Kennedy. At a pro-Palestinian parliamentary meeting, Tonge had said of Palestinian suicide bombers: "If I had to live in that situation – and I say that advisedly – I might just consider becoming one myself". She repeated her comments on Sky News, but added, "I do not condone suicide bombers, nobody can condone them".[12] Tonge refused to apologise, commenting "I was just trying to say how, having seen the violence and the humiliation and the provocation that the Palestinian people live under every day and have done since their land was occupied by Israel, I could understand".[13][14]

Kennedy said her comments were "completely unacceptable" and "not compatible with Liberal Democrat party policies and principles", adding "there can be no justification, under any circumstances for taking innocent lives through terrorism".[13][15] Tonge said that suicide bombers' actions are "appalling and loathsome" but that "we have to try and understand where they are coming from and understand the situation in which they live."[16][17]

Tonge retired from the House of Commons at the 2005 general election,[7] and was made a life peer and member of the House of Lords later in the year.[18]

Life peer

Allegations about the Israel lobby (2006)

Tonge remarked at a Liberal Democrat party conference fringe meeting in September 2006: "The pro-Israeli lobby has got its grips on the western world, its financial grips. I think they've probably got a grip on our party".[19]

In response, Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell wrote to Tonge, commenting that her unacceptable assertion had "clear anti-Semitic connotations".[20][21] An all-party group of peers led by the former Archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey, said, in a letter to The Times, that "the language deployed by Baroness Tonge, as a member of the House of Lords, was irresponsible and inappropriate".[22] At a later meeting at Edinburgh University the following November, Tonge said that professors Stephen Walt and John Mearsheimer's article "The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy" which appeared in the 23 March 2006 issue of the London Review of Books supported her assertion that the "Israel lobby had a disproportionate voice in Anglo-American foreign policy". She said her comments "were about the Israeli lobby in politics. They were a big distance from being about Jewishness or anti-Semitism".[21][23]

The Gaza strip and other issues (2008–10)

In November 2008, Tonge visited the Gaza Strip again, this time with Lord Ahmed, Clare Short, and members of the European Parliament.[24]

From 8 January 2009 to 12 February 2010, Tonge was the Liberal Democrat Spokesperson for Health. On 12 January 2009, Tonge asked in the House of Lords about investigations into alleged Israeli war crimes in the December 2009–January 2010 Gaza War, saying:

Is the Minister aware that Mrs Pillay, the new UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, has spoken of war crimes being committed in Gaza? Will the Government, therefore, show leadership and call for the immediate—and I mean immediate—establishment by the United Nations Security Council of an independent fact-finding commission to Palestine to investigate all breaches of international law?[25]

In March 2009, Tonge joined a six-person delegation of British politicians which met with Hamas political leader Khaled Meshaal in Syria. Tonge told an interviewer that their goal was to force the British government to talk to Hamas and press the United States to do likewise. She stated: "You don't make peace by talking to your friends. You make peace by talking to your enemies", and said she knew that her meeting with Meshaal might be considered illegal and lead to her arrest. "That is one of the risks that you take", she said.[26][27]

During the 2008–2009 Gaza War, Tonge spoke at a London rally against the war, saying: "It is a disgusting, obscene outrage what is going on in Gaza". She said that eventually activists must look to "a full trade embargo and boycotting everything Israeli".[28]

On 1 February 2010, The Palestine Telegraph, of which Tonge was then a patron, published an article which made false claims[29][30][31][32][33] that an Israel Defence Forces emergency aid hospital in Haiti (deployed in the aftermath the 2010 Haiti earthquake) was secretly harvesting organs and selling them on the black market, based partly on a report made on Hezbollah's Al-Manar television which cited a YouTube video produced by a group called AfriSynergy Productions. The video did not cite any evidence, nor did it portray any actual organ removal.[34][35][36][37] She later resigned as a patron of The Palestine Telegraph after it published a video of an interview with American neo-Nazi David Duke.[38]

On 11 February, The Jewish Chronicle published an article containing a statement by Tonge which congratulated the IDF on its swift and generous response to the emergency in Haiti, and said: "To prevent allegations such as these—which have already been posted on YouTube—going any further, the IDF and the Israeli Medical Association [sic] should establish an independent inquiry immediately to clear the names of the team in Haiti."[39]

On 12 February 2010, Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg removed her from her position as health spokeswoman in the House of Lords calling the comments "wrong, distasteful and provocative". The released statement said she had apologised "unreservedly" for any offence she had caused and that neither Clegg nor Tonge gave the allegations "any credence whatsoever". In an email message sent to an anti-Israel activist, Tonge wrote that she had called for an inquiry to dispel any rumours and that the idea that organs could be being harvested in the situation which existed in Haiti was ludicrous and nonsense.[35][40][41][42]

Comments about Israel and the Gaza strip (2012–2021)

In 2012, Tonge appeared at an Israeli Apartheid Week talk at Middlesex University on 23 February 2012,[43][better source needed] during which she said: "Beware Israel. Israel is not going to be there forever in its present form. One day, the United States of America will get sick of giving £70bn a year to Israel to support what I call America's aircraft carrier in the Middle East – that is Israel. One day, the American people are going to say to the Israel lobby in the USA: enough is enough. Israel will lose support and then they will reap what they have sown."[44] A party spokesman said: "Jenny Tonge does not speak for the party on Israel and Palestine. Her presence and comments at this event were extremely ill-advised and ill-judged. The tone of the debate at this event was wholly unacceptable and adds nothing to the peace process. The Liberal Democrats are wholehearted supporters of a peaceful two state solution to the Israel- Palestine issue".[45]

Baroness Tonge resigned the Liberal Democrats whip position immediately after being given an ultimatum by party leader Nick Clegg to apologise or resign for her remarks.[44] From this point onwards, she sat in the House of Lords as an independent Liberal Democrat.[46]

She spoke at a London rally at the Israeli Embassy against the Israeli blockade of the Gaza Strip and the November 2012 Israeli bombings of Gaza in retaliation for militant rocket attacks on Israel.[47]

In January 2015, the New York Jewish newspaper Algemeiner Journal described Tonge as having "a long record of inflammatory, often anti-Semitic, statements against both Israel and the British Jewish leadership" in discussing a written question she had tabled in the Lords,[48] which urged for "Jewish faith leaders in the United Kingdom publicly to condemn settlement building by Israel".[49]

Jonathan Sacerdoti of the Campaign Against Antisemitism told the Algemeiner: "It is despicable to see her using the House of Lords to try to harass Jewish people".[48] In July 2016, Tonge repeated her call for British Jews to condemn Israel resulting in calls from Campaign Against Antisemitism for her to be expelled from the Liberal Democrats.[50]

Following Jeremy Corbyn's election as Leader of the Labour Party, Tonge said that she was considering joining Labour, having not seen the party as left-wing enough until then. Tonge expressed support for Corbyn and the former Labour MP Tony Benn: "I marched alongside Tony Benn and Jeremy Corbyn, one on either side. I went to Gaza with Jeremy Corbyn and we met Hamas leaders together".[51][52] Deputy Labour Leader Tom Watson said Tonge would be "welcome" in the party.[53]

Tonge chaired a meeting of the Palestine Return Council at the House of Lords on 25 October 2016 to launch a campaign for Britain to apologise for the Balfour Declaration, which advocated a home for Jews in Palestine, ahead of its hundredth anniversary in 2017.[54] Jennifer Gerber, the Director of Labour Friends of Israel told The Jewish Chronicle about the absence of any "reproach or redress from Baroness Tonge as chair" at the gathering, at which "attendees compared Israel to ISIS and claimed Jews 'provoked' their own genocide. Silence in the face of such abhorrence amounts to tacit endorsement".[55] Tonge was suspended by the Liberal Democrats, and then resigned from the party on 27 October 2016.[3] Speaking about London's Israeli embassy at the time, she commented: "They are attacking the Lib Dems as they do Labour. They like to be in control of things".[1]

In October 2018, Tonge faced calls to resign over a post she made on Facebook in the aftermath of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting, in which she claimed that the Israeli government's actions towards Palestinians may have contributed to a rise in anti-Semitism.[56] Tonge made a similar comment in January 2021 during a House of Lords debate concerning rising anti-Semitic incidents in universities, saying "The victims are innocent Jewish people—students, in this case. They are victims because of the illegal actions of the Israeli government."[57]

Population, health and development

Tonge is strongly in favour of stem cell research and has stated so in the House of Lords.[58] She is pro-choice on abortion and has supported "Patient (Assisted Dying)" laws in the United Kingdom.[59]

Tonge was chair of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Population, Development and Reproductive Health for five years, which in November 2012 issued a report on child marriage, A Childhood Lost, which urged the British government to act to stop child marriage in Britain and abroad.[60]

This followed other reports on Maternal Morbidity, "Better off Dead", and most recently, a new report has been published on Population Dynamics and Sustainable Development. She was President of the European Parliamentary Forum on Population and Development from 2011-15. In November 2015, she was made an Honorary Fellow of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists for services to women's health in the UK and in developing countries.[citation needed]

Personal life

Tonge met her future husband, Dr Keith Tonge, in 1959, at university.[61] The couple married on 23 May 1964 in Tipton. He was a consultant neuroradiologist, formerly at St Thomas's Hospital in Lambeth; they have two surviving grown children and seven grandchildren. Keith Tonge died on 5 July 2013.[62] Tonge's daughter died by accidental electrocution in 2004.[63]

She lives in Kew and owns property in Hérault, southern France.[61][64][65]


  1. ^ a b Kennedy, Dominic (28 October 2016). "'Jihad Jenny' quits Lib Dems after Holocaust row". The Times. London. Retrieved 11 May 2017. (subscription required)
  2. ^ "No. 57687". The London Gazette. 28 June 2005. p. 8379.
  3. ^ a b Sherwood, Harriet (27 October 2016). "Jenny Tonge quits Lib Dems after suspension for alleged antisemitic comments". The Guardian. Retrieved 27 October 2016.
  4. ^ "Baroness Tonge". UK Parliament. Retrieved 21 February 2021.
  5. ^ Dod's Parliamentary Companion, Vacher Dod Publishing (via google.co.uk); accessed 6 November 2016.
  6. ^ "Profile: Jenny Tonge". BBC News. 23 January 2004.
  7. ^ a b "Baroness Tonge, former MP". theyworkforyou.com. Retrieved 18 January 2009.
  8. ^ Francis Wheen (6 July 2005). How Mumbo-Jumbo Conquered the World: A Short History of Modern Delusions. PublicAffairs. p. 110. ISBN 978-0-7867-2352-2.
  9. ^ McKie, Robin; Bright, Martin (17 March 2002). "In the beginning". The Observer. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  10. ^ "MPs compare Gaza to Warsaw ghetto". The Guardian. Press Association. 19 June 2003. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  11. ^ Chris McGreal, "MP attacked for Nazi comparison", The Guardian, 22 June 2003.
  12. ^ Rozenberg, Gabriel (23 January 2004). "MP to be rebuked over terrorist sympathy". Retrieved 11 May 2017. (subscription required)
  13. ^ a b "Tonge sacked over suicide comment". BBC News. 23 January 2004. Retrieved 16 January 2009.
  14. ^ Russell, Ben (24 January 2004). "Lib Dem MP sacked for saying she could have been suicide bomber". The Independent. Archived from the original on 12 April 2010.
  15. ^ "Lib Dem MP sacked in suicide bomber row". The Times. PA News. 23 January 2004. Retrieved 11 May 2017. (subscription required)
  16. ^ "Tonge sacked over bombing comments". The Guardian. 23 January 2004. Retrieved 4 February 2021.
  17. ^ "Tonge sacked from front bench over suicide comments". The Independent. 24 October 2013. Archived from the original on 8 February 2021. Retrieved 4 February 2021.
  18. ^ https://www.thegazette.co.uk/Edinburgh/issue/25863 [bare URL PDF]
  19. ^ "Tonge condemned for Israel remark". BBC News. 21 September 2006. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  20. ^ "Rebuke for Peer's Israel remarks". BBC News. 13 October 2006. Retrieved 19 December 2008.
  21. ^ a b "Tonge 'in trouble' over comments". BBC News. 27 November 2006. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  22. ^ "Offensive words". The Times. London, UK. 23 September 2006. Retrieved 29 March 2010.
  23. ^ Conger, George (28 November 2006). "British baroness chastised for 'pro-Israel lobby' comments". The Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  24. ^ Sharp, Rob (10 November 2008). "Short boats into Gaza with fact-finding mission". The Independent.
  25. ^ "House of Lords debates". theyworkforyou.com. 12 January 2009.
  26. ^ "UK lawmakers aim to 'force' Hamas talks", CNN, 5 March 2009.
  27. ^ See also MPs meet Hamas leader in Damascus, Reuters, 14 March 2009 (note that attendees including Tonge are identified in photo credits).
  28. ^ Protests held in UK cities in solidarity with people of Gaza, wsws.org, 19 January 2009.
  29. ^ "Haiti organ harvesting claims false". The Jerusalem Post | Jpost.com. Retrieved 26 August 2016.
  30. ^ "Former British MP Tonge: Probe claims of IDF organ theft in Haiti". Ynetnews. ynetnews.com. 12 February 2010. Retrieved 27 August 2016. exploiting the horrible tragedy that has befallen Haiti to recycle false claims that IDF soldiers engage in organ trafficking....
  31. ^ Pogrund, Benjamin (10 July 2014). Drawing Fire: Investigating the Accusations of Apartheid in Israel. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 185. ISBN 9781442226845. she gave credence to ugly, baseless rumors
  32. ^ "The Big Lie Of Israeli 'Organ Harvesting' Resurfaces As YouTube Video On Haiti Earthquake Goes Global". ADL. Retrieved 4 September 2016.
  33. ^ "CFCA - USA – 'Israelis stealing organs in Haiti'". antisemitism.org.il. Retrieved 4 September 2016.
  34. ^ Stephen Lendman, Focus on Israel: "Harvesting Haitian organs?" Archived 2010-02-23 at the Wayback Machine, The Palestine Telegraph, 1 February 2010.
  35. ^ a b Simon Rocker and Martin Bright, "Tonge: Investigate IDF stealing organs in Haiti", The Jewish Chronicle, 11 February 2010.
  36. ^ "Former British MP Tonge: Probe claims of IDF organ theft in Haiti", Ynetnews.com, 12 February 2010.
  37. ^ Haiti organ harvesting claims false by Jonny Paul, Jerusalem Post, 14 February 2010.
  38. ^ Elgot, Jessica (22 April 2010). "Tonge quits Palestine Telegraph 'over KKK video". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 31 March 2018.
  39. ^ Simon Rocker and Martin Bright, Tonge: Investigate IDF stealing organs in Haiti, Jewish Chronicle, 11 February 2010
  40. ^ "Lib Dem health spokeswoman sacked". BBC. 12 February 2010. Retrieved 12 February 2010.
  41. ^ "Baroness Tonge fired over outburst against Israeli soldiers in Haiti". The Daily Telegraph. London, UK. 13 February 2010. Archived from the original on 16 February 2010. Retrieved 6 May 2010.
  42. ^ Jonny Paul,"Tonge fired over organ harvesting remark", Jerusalem Post, 15 February 2010.
  43. ^ "Israeli Apartheid Week: Discussion on "Is Israel an Apartheid State?"". Facebook. 23 February 2012. Retrieved 29 February 2012.
  44. ^ a b Watt, Nicholas (29 February 2012). "Lady Tonge resigns Lib Dem party whip over Israel remarks". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  45. ^ Watt, Nicholas (29 February 2012). "Nick Clegg urged to act after Lib Dem peer says Israel will not last for ever". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  46. ^ James Lyons, "Shameless MPs demand 50% rise in second home allowances so they don't have to use public transport", Daily Mirror, 20 November 2012.
  47. ^ London's March For Gaza Attracts 15,000 Archived 12 November 2013 at the Wayback Machine, Tripoli Post, 24 November 2012.
  48. ^ a b Cohen, Ben (30 January 2015). "Antisemitic British Baroness Jenny Tonge Pressures UK Jews to Condemn Israel". Algemeiner.com. Retrieved 30 April 2016.
  49. ^ "Occupied Territories: Written question - HL4418". Parliament.uk. House of Lords, UK Parliament. Retrieved 30 April 2016.
  50. ^ "Baroness Tonge again demands British Jews condemn Israel". 21 July 2016. Retrieved 22 July 2016.
  51. ^ Woolf, Marie (20 September 2015). "Top Lib Dem warns she may defect to 'honest' Corbyn". The Sunday Times. Retrieved 11 May 2017. (subscription required)
  52. ^ Banham, Mark (20 September 2015). "Liberal Democrat peer Baroness Tonge considers defection to Labour". International Business Times.
  53. ^ "Tom Watson says Jenny Tonge would be 'welcome' in Labour", Jewish News Online, 20 September 2015.
  54. ^ Kennedy, Dominic (27 October 2016). "Jews blamed for Holocaust at 'shameful' House of Lords event". The Times. London. Retrieved 11 May 2017. (subscription required)
  55. ^ Sugarman, Daniel (27 October 2016). "Jenny Tonge suspended by Liberal Democrats". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 27 October 2016.
  56. ^ Forrest, Adam (28 October 2018). "Former Lib Dem peer faces calls to be removed from Lords over 'antisemitic' post about Pittsburgh shooting". The Independent. Retrieved 29 October 2018.
  57. ^ Harpin, Lee. "Fury as Tonge blames rising UK campus antisemitism on 'the illegal actions of the Israeli government'". www.thejc.com. Retrieved 4 February 2021.
  58. ^ "Column 1605". publications.parliament.uk. 29 October 2008. Retrieved 19 January 2009.
  59. ^ Ann Farmer, By Their Fruits: Eugenics, Population Control, and the Abortion Campaign, CUA Press, 2008, pg. 261
  60. ^ Maria Caspani, UK MPs call on government to act decisively to stop child marriage Archived 16 April 2013 at archive.today, Reuter's TrustLaw, 29 November 2012.
  61. ^ a b "Profile: Jenny Tonge". BBC News. 23 January 2004. Retrieved 16 January 2009.
  62. ^ "Obituary – Dr Keith Angus Tonge". Your Local Guardian. 5 July 2013. Retrieved 28 July 2013.
  63. ^ "Coroner verdict on MP's daughter". BBC. 12 October 2004. Retrieved 16 January 2009.
  64. ^ Changes to the Register of Members' Interests, Theyworkforyou.com.
  65. ^ Tonge, Jenny (16 April 2010). "Volcano's shadow may fall on UK ecomony [sic], but not on Heathrow flight path". The Guardian. London, UK. Retrieved 9 May 2017.
Parliament of the United Kingdom
New constituency Member of Parliament
for Richmond Park

Succeeded by